7 days of Economics - ECB forward guidance: well-intended vagueness
December 15, 2017 at 08:22 pm IST
Share
Mario Draghi's press conference yesterday has added a word to the list of important yet vague words in ECB speak: 'close'. Is the projection of 1.7% inflation in 2020 sufficiently close to the objective of 'close to but below 2%'? Unsurprisingly the answer to the journalist's thoughtful question was not clear and the ECB president has every interest in being vague. Firstly, as he explained so eloquently, it depends on the environment: is such a level of inflation sustainable in the absence of the current accommodative stance? Secondly, a point which he didn't mention, a central banker doesn't want to be locked-in: labelling 1.7% as 'close enough' today would cause market anticipation of policy change well before this level would be reached thereby weighing on the effectiveness of the current policy in supporting growth and inflation dynamics.
For the very same reason that other key word is not defined either: 'well past'. Current policy rates will be maintained well past the end of QE. The refusal to provide a definition is again based on the idea of avoiding to tie one's hands, to precommit based on data thresholds or a specific date. Investors may feel left behind empty-handed: although risk and uncertainty generate the extra return over and above the risk-free rate they strive for, they hate uncertainty so in their dreams guidance is clear and 'close' and 'well past' are precisely defined. However, such a dream could end up in a nightmare: the environment might change forcing the central bank to renege on its earlier guidance. Investors would wake up with a headache and volatility would increase structurally because everybody would understand that firmly stated guidance is of little value in a world which is rife with 'known unknowns'. Out would go the credibility of the central bank. At the end of the day, guidance should be sufficiently clear whilst remaining…sufficiently vague. It's in the interest of the speaker (the central bank) and his audience (markets).
BNP Paribas SA published this content on 15 December 2017 and is solely responsible for the information contained herein. Distributed by Public, unedited and unaltered, on 15 December 2017 14:51:05 UTC.
Original documenthttps://group.bnpparibas/en/news/7-days-economics-ecb-guidance-well-intended-vagueness
Public permalinkhttp://www.publicnow.com/view/E7A5C147C2924D89CDDA4089AB78792C90D96432
BNP Paribas is France's largest banking group. Net banking product (NBP) breaks down by activity as follows:
- retail banking (54%): retail banking activity in France (24.1% of NBP), in Belgium (14.6%), and Italy (10.2%). The remainder of the NBP (51.1%) is from international activities and specialized financial services activities (consumer loans, real estate credit, leasing credit, car fleet management, computer equipment leasing);
- finance and investment banking (34.4%): consulting and capital market activities (83.7% of NBP; merger-acquisition consulting, activities related to the stock, interest, and exchange markets, etc.) and financing (16.3%; financing for acquisitions, projects, raw material transactions, etc.);
- institutional and private management and insurance (11.6%): asset management, private banking activity (No. 1 in France), real estate and on-line brokerage services, insurance and securities services (No. 1 in Europe for retained securities).
At the end of 2023, BNP Paribas was managing EUR 988.5 billion in current deposits and EUR 859.2 billion in current loans.
Net banking product is distributed geographically as follows: Europe, Middle East and Africa (82.9%), America (9.8%) and Asia/Pacific (7.3%).